Monday January 27, 2014 When New York-New Jersey got its Super Bowl ... and I was there
Updated: 4:18pm, January 27
Updated: 4:18pm, January 27
GAINESVILLE, Fla. -- The Super Bowl XLVIII dog and pony shows commenced Sunday night with the New Jersey/New York (depends what side of the river you're on) arrivals of the Denver Broncos and Seattle Seahawks.
In the coming days, our readers at GatorZone.com surely will be interested in how the University of Florida connections fare, with Seahawks' defensive coordinator Dan Quinn and wide receiver Percy Harvin, figuring prominently in Sunday night's big game. On the Broncos side, wideout Andre Caldwell and Jerome Mincey will represent.
In my previous life as an NFL writer, I covered 13 Super Bowls, mostly during my run with the Orlando Sentinel, and certainly had my fill of Media Day moments. One of my favorites came in 1991 at Tampa Stadium. When the Buffalo Bills were done with their session, All-Pro defensive stars Bruce Smith and Cornelius Bennett climbed down from their podiums, stepped over the ropes and walked together across the pristine manicured grass on the way to the team's locker room.
A groundskeeper yelled at them.
"Hey!" he shouted. "You guys aren't allowed on the field!"
Smith's response: "Oh yeah? Come move us!"
That was more than two decades ago and Media Day has mushroom-clouded from overexposure.
I can't wait to see the mob scene at Richard Sherman's podium Tuesday, which likely will rival the Ray Lewis scene at Raymond James Stadium in Tampa 13 years ago (minus the questions a murder case). The over-under on inane questions during the day is off the board. Ditto the number of man hugs Stuart Scott gives players. Oh, and someone will be wearing a Captain America, Green Lantern or Batman-like costume, and because the event will be held indoors -- rather at MetLife Stadium, where temperatures will be around 15 degrees Tuesday morning -- let's not forget the voluptuous Telemundo correspondents who will get every single one of their ridiculous questions answered ... and rightfully so.
The hottest topic of the week, of course, will be the coldest Super Bowl in history. Extended forecasts for next Sunday call for highs in the mid-30s, with temperatures dipping below freezing, with a chance of snow showers.
Imagine for a second, if this game turns into a blowout, and fans decide they've seen enough (after Bruno Mars and friends play halftime). Empty seats at a Super Bowl will make for a great photo op, but the NFL will get what it deserves (whatever that may be) and be just fine. Better than fine.
It's "The King."
The game could end up being a winter classic, but all the run-up this week made me think about the run-up to a Super Bowl being placed in the Northeast -- outdoors, no less -- in the first place. What were they thinking? Answer: they weren't.
Four years ago, I was a senior NFL writer for AOL's Fanhouse.com, I attended the league meetings near Dallas, where the owners met to vote on the site of the 2014 Super Bowl. Some called the outcome a fait accompli. It was more like a kangaroo court. The New York Giants and Jets had committed to building a $1.6 billion stadium, so New York (make that New Jersey, but you get the idea) was goign to get a Super Bowl.
My story from May 24, 2010.
By Chris Harry
Senior NFL Writer
IRVING, Texas -- So they want to play a Super Bowl in New York City, eh?
The host clubs in the bidding process, the Giants and Jets, have teamed up to embrace the cold-weather element and want the league’s championship game to go “old school,” as quarterback Eli Manning put it. The motto for New York push is “Let’s Make Some History.”
First, let’s relive some history.
Rewind 10 years ago to Super Bowl weekend in Atlanta.
A sluggish winter storm dripped a crippling coating of ice on much of the Southeast today, cracking thousands of drooping pine trees and cutting off electric power to more than 500,000 households, mostly in Atlanta. City and football officials spent the day trying to reassure the public that the weather could not hurt their plans for this season’s grandest spectacle, Super Bowl XXXIV, on Sunday, because the game will be played in a dome. City and state road crews scattered salt and sand on roads throughout the Atlanta metropolitan area as the National Weather Service predicted the temperatures would hover around freezing with occasional freezing rain through the day.
Other items in The Atlanta Journal-Constitution detailed how the Georgia Department of Transportation had to suspend shuttle service between Super Bowl hotels and the Georgia Dome, the game’s site. That sand spread on the streets for traction iced over. Sixteen power generators were brought to the dome in case ice and snow knocked out power downtown. Travel on Interstates 75 and 85, the north-south freeways through the city, were at a 5-10 mph crawl all weekend. Interstate-20, the east-west route, came to a standstill after a 49-car pile-up. President Clinton declared 30 Georgia counties disaster areas.
“The weather has had some impact on some of the events surrounding the game,” NFL spokesman Greg Aiello said. “Some people haven’t been able to get into town because their flights were canceled.”
“In 18 years, this is the most ice I’ve ever seen accumulate,” Weather Channel senior meteorologist Tom Moore said.
“The game should go on and people should be able to see it,” Georgia Power spokesperson Carol Boatright assured.
Remember that weekend, NFL?
Now take those Atlanta scenes 850 miles north, to one of the most densely populated areas in the world, and a region that just had 37 feet of snow in the Super Bowl month of February, the most in 140 years. “Snowmaggeden.”
Oh, and one more thing: play the game outdoors.
Super Bowl meet Super Brrrr.
Barring a stunning upset, the NFL is expected to vote the 2014 Super Bowl to New York City when the league convenes for its spring meetings Tuesday at the Omni Hotel-Las Colinas. Commissioner Roger Goodell does not have a vote, but the man with the big office in Manhattan has made it clear to the league’s 32 owners -- publicly and privately -- that he wants the NFL’s grand spectacle to be played at the new $1.6 billion Meadowlands stadium, set to open this season and be shared by the Giants and Jets, in East Rutherford, N.J.
“I think it can be very attractive to the ownership and to the NFL in general,” Goodell said.
Goodell usually gets what he wants, having shown his considerable influence in March when he rammed through controversial new overtime rules for the postseason during the league’s annual meetings. The OT proposals were unpopular with some teams (and lots of coaches), yet passed by a 28-4 vote.
The NFL already has rewarded Dallas and Indianapolis for building palatial new stadiums with Super Bowls. Goodell’s home teams -- potential for an Ice Bowl and all -- are up next.
South Florida and Tampa, which have hosted a combined 14 Super Bowls, also are bidding on the game, but the balloting for this one already has the feel of an Iranian election. Some of the most prominent owners in the league, including New England’s Robert Kraft, are in Goodell’s corner and want it to happen.
“Our league was founded on winter football,” Kraft told The New York Daily News last week. “Our sport is about resilience, mental toughness, adjustments. I think it will be a great experience for the fans. A memorable experience.”
A faction of owners, mostly from destination-city franchises, would prefer the league not open a cold-weather can of worms. If New York, what about Washington, Philadelphia, Baltimore, Chicago, et al?
“I’m OK with an open-air Super Bowl,” Cincinnati Bengals owner Mike Brown said at NFL meetings two months ago. “As long as it’s in Florida.”
Each city will give a 15-minute presentation touting its bid, after which owners will cast their votes. If one of the city’s gets a three-quarters majority (24 votes), it gets the game. If not, the city with the least votes is eliminated and a second vote is taken between the two remaining candidates, with only a 17-vote simple majority needed.
“It's time for the biggest game in football to be played on the biggest stage in the world,” Jets owner Woody Johnson and Giants treasurer Jonathan Tisch, bid committee chairmen, said in a joint statement released by the New York group. “We are confident that the appeal and prestige of the New York City metropolitan region, coupled with the innovative capabilities of our brand-new state-of-the-art facility, can provide a unique and exciting experience for the teams and fans, as well as the entire league and the sport of football.”
The road to rubber-stamping the experience began in December when the NFL’s Super Bowl Advisory Committee waived a rule that required the Super Bowl to be played at climate-controlled indoor stadiums or at outdoor sites where the average temperature is no less than 50 degrees.
Once that hurdle was eliminated -- presumably at Goodell’s behest -- New York became the front-runner.
Former Indianapolis coach Tony Dungy, now an analyst with NBC and winner of Super Bowl XLI in rainy Miami three years ago, questioned how a guideline for making the game fair for both teams, and comfortable for the fans, became so unimportant.
“Now, all of a sudden, we’re saying, ‘Oh well, that used to be the rule, but it doesn’t matter anymore,’ ‘’ Dungy told FanHouse last week. “Obviously, for 43 years we said that it [mattered]. We didn’t allow it. And while I understand New York has a beautiful new stadium and would be a great place to have a Super Bowl from a media interest standpoint. But if I was coaching, I’d certainly want the best conditions for the game ... and you don’t know if you’re going to get that in New York.”
How would Dungy’s world-championship team of ’06, led by Peyton Manning, fared in the Super Bowl if that Miami rain had been a New Jersey sleet storm against the weather-worn Chicago Bears? What if Kurt Warner and the ’99 St. Louis Rams, “The Greatest Show on Turf,” had been rewarded for their spectacular pass-happy season by facing the Tennessee Titans in those infamous 30-mph winds at Giants Stadium?
“I’ve been in some bad Meadowlands games in November, but that’s part of the game,” Dungy said. “But I don’t know that it’s right to do it [for the Super Bowl] based on the rules that we had in place for more than 40 years.”
Proponents of the New York push will point out that the average high temperature in East Rutherford the first week in February is 38 degrees; with the average low is 22 degrees. Those aren’t exactly Arctic conditions.
They’re not ideal, either.
“I like the Super Bowl where the elements don’t have any factor in the game,” Jets wide receiver Santonio Holmes, MVP of Super Bowl XLII in Tampa as a member of the Pittsburgh Steelers, told reporters last week. “I would prefer to keep all Super Bowls somewhere in the South. I don’t want to play anywhere where it’s cold. We play it enough during the season.”
The NFL Players Association has not taken an official position on the issue.
“From a player’s standpoint, I would imagine any team would be excited to be in a Super Bowl and have a chance to win a championship. Where it is would be of secondary importance,” said veteran Dolphins quarterback Chad Pennington, who played eight seasons with the Jets. “But I just think it would be a no-brainer to want to be in warm weather rather than cold weather -- for anybody, including those people in New York.”
The fans, the ones paying $2,000 per ticket, have not been asked how they feel. The answer is fairly obvious.
They’ll feel cold.
Back to Atlanta 10 years ago.
"Of course, all of this ice, all these cold and frigid conditions, are putting a little bit of a damper on the festivities here on Super Bowl weekend. There are some parties taking place in Buckhead, the Bud Bowl party. But the attendance there, probably not as much as people had hoped. And again, the festive atmosphere probably not as great as it had been hoped for Super Bowl weekend. But again, the Super Bowl will be held here in spite of all the ice, in spite of the rain, in spite of a little bit of sleet. It’s be held right behind me here in the dome, and, of course, the weather will be fine there tomorrow: 72 degrees. That’ll please both the fans and the players. I’m Brian Cabell, CNN, live in Atlanta."
Dress warmly. And bring a shovel, just in case.